Can we discuss trimming techniques?

[waterfaller1]

I would like to learn proper trimming in detail. Please if you have any tips or techniques,do share them. I did read this article which was very helpful, but have many questions.
AquaScaping World Magazine - Trimmng Stem Plants

I suppose I have to wait for the plants to grow full before even attempting any shape, or is it something you do as they grow? After trimming, how do you get all those little bits of clippings out of the tank? Do you trim with the filter running, or turn it off? Do you suggest trimming the tops of the plants only? I was told when I started, to uproot the plant and only replant the tops. This seems like it would constantly upset the substrate and shock the plant. Any help greatly appreciated.

[J House]

Originally Posted by waterfaller1

I would like to learn proper trimming in detail. Please if you have any tips or techniques,do share them. I did read this article which was very helpful, but have many questions.
AquaScaping World Magazine - Trimmng Stem Plants

I suppose I have to wait for the plants to grow full before even attempting any shape, or is it something you do as they grow? After trimming, how do you get all those little bits of clippings out of the tank? Do you trim with the filter running, or turn it off? Do you suggest trimming the tops of the plants only? I was told when I started, to uproot the plant and only replant the tops. This seems like it would constantly upset the substrate and shock the plant. Any help greatly appreciated.

Generally speaking you want to trim and discard(sell/trade) the tops of most stem plants. Replanting and removing the bottoms is just not realistic in most cases and will take your enjoyment away from the hobby. Yes it's true, if you replant the tops you will have a better looking stem almost instantly, but if you keep the bottoms intact the group of stems will be fuller and more attractive within no time due to multiple leaders coming from the cut. If you have hardscape in and around the stems try to cut and follow the height and shape of the rock or wood. It will really give you a dense and natural looking scape.

BTW-The cut stems can usually be removed easily with a net.

[waterfaller1]

Thanks so much for your reply. I see how this is an important element to the aquascape, even if it's a natural style...you don't want it too wild. There are so many great aquarists that have joined ASW,it is wonderful to have such great teachers!

[Dave Spencer]

One thing to remember is to trim in 3D. A lot of people trim from side to side to get a nice shape, but not always from front to back.

Trimming the stems shorter at the front, and leaving them taller towards the rear helps to hide the actual stems themselves, and enhance the bushy appearance.

Dave.

[John N.]

Originally Posted by Dave Spencer

One thing to remember is to trim in 3D. A lot of people trim from side to side to get a nice shape, but not always from front to back.

This is very true and a great tip. One of the greatest ways to make an aquascape appear larger in its space is to shape plants in both height and depth.

Our April 2008 Aquascape of the Month, Cosmopolis is a fine example of well executed 3-D layout.

Some Key Trimming Techniques

• Trim with filter flow off
• Trim/replant plants with 1/3 tank full of water
• Replant from front of the tank first, and then make your way to the back of your aquarium.
  • Drape your plants on top of each other as you move towards the back. By doing this you will have the background completely exposed so that you can replant properly without having to plug your stems with your other newly planted stems in the way. I hope that make sense...if it doesn't I'm sure someone will reword what I'm trying to say.

-John N.