I feel it completely depends on the goals one hopes to achieve in an aquascape. When scaping, one should have a clear view of what they want to create, and depending on the desired outcome, one should know immediately which to use.
A more natural, lush scape is complimented by a combination of rock and stone, whereas a serene Iwagumi requires only stone. This is not to say that an Iwagumi hardscape comes cheaper and easier, as acquiring the right stone, and the right amount, can be a daunting task. The stone requires texture, and each piece needs to compliment the next in a manner that helps it all come together. Not only are these beautiful pieces expensive, but often very hard to find.
Wood, whether it be Manzanita, Malaysian, or ADA Old Black wood, also demands precison in choice and placement. I feel that with wood, it's critical just as it is with rock to find the right pieces.
Both stone and wood require much thorough thought for a design to be truely outstanding. One can attain the best hardscape materials in the world, but if they are not placed, positioned, and used properly, the scape will not come together. Patience is required when striving to create a pleasing hardscape, as everything does not come together all at one. Small revisions have to be made over time, and a fresh set of eyes always helps.
The hardscape is the foundation on which the entire aquascape lies, don't shrug it off and say you can make up for it with the plants. It's the backbone to all great scapes.
|